| Category | Vanta | Scrut |
|---|---|---|
| Philosophy | Streamlined compliance with broad integrations and automated checks | All-in-one GRC with deep customization, proactive onboarding, and comprehensive dashboards |
| Framework Coverage | ~27 frameworks available, add-ons often priced per framework | 50+ out-of-the-box frameworks plus custom frameworks and local regulations included |
| Evidence & Audits | Audit Center consolidates artifacts, strong for single frameworks | Audit Center centralizes multi-framework audits, invite auditors, real-time task tracking |
| Continuous Monitoring | Broad connectors, continuous checks, growing ecosystem | Always-on monitoring, uniform automation, daily scans against 230+ CIS Benchmarks |
| Risk Management | Built-in module with predefined matrix and basic scoring | Dynamic risk register, inherent and residual scoring, custom formulas, risk-to-control mapping |
| Support | Self-serve templates with partner network, time-zone limited support | 24/7 support rated highly on G2, hands-on onboarding, monthly and quarterly reviews |
| Pricing | Often per-framework pricing and feature gating at higher tiers | All-features-inclusive platform designed to scale without add-ons |
Secureframe, Vanta, and Scrut are three prominent players in modern compliance automation. Each brings a different philosophy to the same problem. Secureframe prioritizes simplicity for fast onboarding. Vanta leans on a large integration ecosystem to help teams monitor multiple frameworks. Scrut focuses on deeper customization, proactive implementation support, and rich dashboards that scale across industries and company sizes.
This page compares Vanta and Scrut across the categories that matter most: supported frameworks, evidence and audits, continuous monitoring, risk, integrations, support, and pricing approach. If you value ease of use, advanced risk management, or heavy customization, you will find clear guidance below on which platform aligns with your goals.
A broader native library reduces the number of tools you need as you scale.
ISO 27001:2022 and extensions, SOC 2, PCI DSS, GDPR, Microsoft SSPA, HIPAA, CCPA and others. Several customized or advanced frameworks are available at higher prices.
50+ out-of-the-box frameworks including SOC 2, ISO 27001, PCI DSS, CCPA, CIS Controls, HIPAA, Microsoft SSPA, FERPA, COPPA, NIST CSF, CSA CCM, FedRAMP, ISO 27017, NIST AI RMF, SOX, ISO 22301, ISO 27018, CMMC, NIST 800-53, NIST 800-171, plus custom frameworks and local regulations.
Takeaway: If your roadmap includes multiple standards or regional frameworks, Scrut's breadth helps you avoid per-framework upsells and duplicate work.
Vanta streamlines evidence collection with an Audit Center that pulls artifacts into a single place. Users report reduced audit stress thanks to policies, risk registers, templates, and automation. Confusion can arise around pricing tiers and timelines, and support availability may vary by time zone.
Scrut's Audit Center runs simultaneous audits across frameworks. Invite auditors directly, assign responsibilities, track tasks in real time, and share only what is necessary. Documentation is collected automatically from connected systems to produce time-stamped, audit-ready evidence and a clean audit trail.
Verdict: Both reduce manual effort. Scrut offers stronger multi-framework orchestration and in-platform collaboration with auditors.
Vanta offers continuous monitoring with a growing integration list. It enforces checks and alerts on drift. Some users note high pricing and vendor-specific gaps, and have flagged differences in monitoring depth between tools such as CloudWatch and Datadog.
Scrut provides always-on monitoring as a default posture, not a premium add-on. It scans cloud configurations and vulnerabilities daily against 230+ CIS Benchmarks across major cloud vendors, keeps post-certification monitoring active, and centralizes alerts so teams can triage quickly.
Verdict: Both deliver continuous checks. Scrut's uniform access to automation and scanning avoids paywalled monitoring features and helps teams standardize compliance operations across environments.
The risk module lets teams score risks in a predefined matrix and track status. It is useful for basic programs. Some customers report limited impact mapping, feature gating for advanced risk, and less flexibility for edge cases.
Scrut treats risk as a first-class citizen. Build from a pre-vetted risk library or create your own risks. Use expert scoring methods to quantify inherent and residual risk. Map risks to specific controls across frameworks like ISO 27001, SOC 2, and HIPAA. Auto-populate mitigations, assign owners, and choose accept, mitigate, transfer, or avoid. Track metrics and trigger alerts when thresholds are crossed. Support for custom risk formulas and risk scoring enables business-specific governance.
Verdict: Scrut offers deeper, data-driven risk workflows for organizations that want continuous oversight and clear lines from risk to control to remediation.
Vanta connects to a wide range of cloud, HRIS, ticketing, and security tools, and continues to expand. Several advanced integrations live behind higher tiers. Companies with niche stacks sometimes rely on manual uploads.
Scrut integrates with AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, AWS Identity Center, Microsoft Defender, HR platforms, DevOps, and more. It supports custom API integrations and can help build new connectors for your stack. The goal is a unified, scalable compliance layer that grows with your architecture rather than forcing manual workarounds.
Verdict: Both integrate widely. Scrut emphasizes depth, customization, and the ability to extend coverage without pushing you into higher pricing bands for essential connectors.
Clean dashboards display compliance progress and risk heatmaps. Automated vendor discovery is available at higher tiers. The experience works well for straightforward programs that need visibility and standardized checks.
Actionable dashboards show a consolidated security and compliance posture with drill-down reporting on risk metrics, framework status, vendor assurance, and pending tasks. Custom workflows support multi-approval reviews for key artifacts, preventing rubber-stamp governance and improving audit defensibility.
Verdict: Vanta's views are simple and effective. Scrut's dashboards and workflows focus on operationalizing compliance and risk at scale.
Users praise the platform for simplifying compliance. Feedback commonly asks for clearer control descriptions, more transparent pricing, and faster access to live guidance during onboarding.
24/7 support with high user ratings on G2. Hands-on onboarding, technical help, and periodic reviews keep programs on track. Some users mention a learning curve as they adopt advanced features, but report quick resolutions and a friendly interface.
Verdict: If you want white-glove help through setup and change management, Scrut is purpose-built for guided implementation and ongoing reviews.
Often priced per framework, with advanced features and integrations at higher tiers. This can complicate budgeting for teams that plan to add standards over time.
All-features-inclusive approach designed to scale without constant add-ons or per-framework fees, making budgeting more predictable for growing companies.
Verdict: For a single framework and a standard stack, Vanta fits well. For multi-framework roadmaps or teams that want to avoid per-framework costs, Scrut is easier to plan and scale.
Support for roughly 27 frameworks
Continuous monitoring with growing integration list
Dashboard for compliance progress and risk heatmaps
Automated vendor discovery at higher tiers
Audit Center for artifact collection and readiness
One-stop compliance across 50+ frameworks, 90+ policy templates, and 1,400+ unified controls
White-glove compliance support from onboarding to certification
Quantified risk profile with inherent and residual scoring, custom formulas, and control mapping
Automated evidence collection across cloud, SaaS, DevOps, HR, and more
Actionable dashboards with consolidated posture and drill-down views
Continuous monitoring with daily CIS benchmark scans and real-time alerts
Customizable multi-approval workflows and vendor portal with questionnaire automation
Both Vanta and Scrut help teams move away from spreadsheets and toward automation. Vanta delivers a streamlined experience backed by a broad integration ecosystem. Scrut goes further on customization, risk, and multi-framework operations, and includes hands-on guidance as a core part of the platform.
If your priority is a comprehensive compliance and risk platform that goes beyond audit readiness with continuous monitoring, real-time risk alerts, policy automation, and unified security governance, Scrut is the better fit.
Vanta often prices per framework and places some advanced features at higher tiers. Scrut uses an all-features-inclusive model designed to scale without per-framework upsells.
For companies that expect to add frameworks or expand into new regions, Scrut's 50+ frameworks, 90+ policy templates, 1,400+ controls, and wide integrations make scaling simpler and more cost-predictable.
Scrut streamlines compliance with automated evidence collection, quantified risk, daily CIS cloud scans, and multi-approval workflows. It is built to operationalize compliance and risk in one place, with guided onboarding and 24/7 support that keeps programs moving.
If your goal is to get certified fast and use that certification to win enterprise clients, Smartly is the smarter starting point.
Unlike broader GRC platforms that serve larger, process-heavy organizations, Smartly is built specifically for startups and growing tech teams that want to move quickly and stay focused on product and growth.
Smartly automates 70% of the manual prep work and helps teams achieve ISO 27001 readiness in weeks, not months. You stay focused on your roadmap while Smartly handles the compliance lift.
You pay to get certified, not for extra services along the way. Every plan covers implementation, templates, audit coordination, and certification, no hidden costs.
Designed for startups with lean budgets, Smartly delivers enterprise-grade compliance at a fraction of the usual price, no consultants, no overhead.
Certification isn't just a checkbox. With Smartly, it becomes a growth enabler that helps you close enterprise deals, expand globally, and build customer trust early.
If your focus is to prove trust fast and unlock new business, Smartly gives you the fastest and most affordable path to ISO 27001 success.